Mary Warren: Chelsea Beatty/Elizabeth Robinson*

Abigail Williams: Holly Cameron/Margaret Felice*

Elizabeth Proctor: Julia Teitel/Amanda Robie*

Rebecca Nurse: Christina Calamaio/Rachel Selan*

Ann Putnam: Amy Dancz/Leah Hungerford*

Sarah Good: Vanessa Julia Isiguen/Heather Finch*

John Proctor: Sepp Hammer/Bradford Gleim*

Thomas Putnam: Joel Buford^/Andrew Wannigman°

Tituba: Jodie Marie Fernandes

Francis Nurse: Brooklyn Rohm

Rev. Parris: James Onstad

Giles Corey: Adrian Jones

Ezekial Cheever: John Paul Putney/Barratt Park*

Judge Danforth: Sean Malkus

Rev. Hale: Matthew Wight

Betty Parris: Hilary Walker

Bridget Booth: Erin Holmes

Ruth Putnam: Emily Burr^/Sarah Morrow°

Martha Sheldon: Sara Oettinger

Mercy Lewis: Desiree Maira

Susanna Walcott: Renée Hites